Pack idea - Single song pack

[leonid]

I'm interested in seeing how stepauthors' stepping styles differ from one another. Here's a pack I'd like to see being made:

1) Pack chooses a single song and distributes it to the people. They are allowed to step this song only.
2) Every simfile is accepted without being judged by the pack director.
3) Simfiles have identical gfx and cdtitle. Difficulties are based on NPS. Titles are numbered so that people can properly review simfiles without confusion.
4) Reviews are pm'd to the pack director so that one's reviews don't affect the others'.
5) When enough number of reviews are gathered, pack director releases all the reviews and reveals stepauthors for each simfile.

Any thoughts?

[emulord]

That sounds fun. One of my friends was talking about having a Ctrl-R style stepping competition. Thats kind of only something you can do IRL.

[Staiain]

This is a cool idea, count me in (Don't make it a looooong song though)

[emulord]

The best part is the organizer can sync the file at the start! Thats the least fun part of stepping! woooooo

Edit: Oh yeah, I'd do this if we were given a blank, sync'd .sm file

[Zovistograt]

I'm interested in participating unless the song sucks :3

[Shikari]

Great idea, so you can see how different is each style, without rating them "good" or "bad". I'm in.

[Roar176]

Stoopid Snoozing Idea

because (I explain because Ur my buddy Leoniddo):
- Restricted song choice = nobody will contribute
- Reviews = I hate reviews
- Single = Single sucks

but besides this it would show who's the best in the business

FAQ:

Why nobody will contribute ??
This isn't confirmed but when you restrict the song choice to 66 amzin bemani songs nobody steps them.

Why do I hate reviews ??
Because I don't step file for your asses LoL I don't need your feedback therefore I hate reviews (o:

Why single sucks ??
Because ...
tldr: single sucks

[TC_Cyrenics]

In. That is all.

[Jousway]

so its like the "Mystery Pack" but its the same song all the time

[who_cares973]

I've always wondered how different files would differ stepartist to stepartist on a universal song. Awesome idea


In and yeah please make the song under 2:30

[FFR4EVA_00]

maaan when i read this i thought you meant that you were gonna make a pack with only one file in it as part of a stepmania commentary
i'm doing it unless the song you choose is gay

[leonid]

Originally Posted by who_cares973

In and yeah please make the song under 2:30

The song I'm thinking of is 3:37 long. Would this be ok

Otherwise suggest some epic short songs plz

[blindreper1179]

would totally be in for this. now i need to hurry up and buy a new computer. but yeah, 3 max, playing the same long song will get boring quick before playing all the different simfiles.

[AsphyxZero]

how about another mystery pack

[i love you]

I really REALLY like this idea. Count me in.

PS: I think it would be better if the song is under 2:30 so that way, more people would step the song.

[customstuff]

I reeeally like this idea

[kaiten123]

pretty cool idea

[Oni-Paranoia]

Originally Posted by Roar176

Stoopid Snoozing Idea

because (I explain because Ur my buddy Leoniddo):
- Restricted song choice = nobody will contribute
- Reviews = I hate reviews
- Single = Single sucks

Next time you want to point out a dumb idea, make sure you don't speak from only your perspective because...

- Clearly people are willing to contribute already
- No one cares if you hate reviews
- Your opinion on singles isn't everyone's

Originally Posted by leonid

The song I'm thinking of is 3:37 long. Would this be ok

Otherwise suggest some epic short songs plz

Cut the song?

[leonid]

Troll success Roar lmao
I found a shorter song, so don't worry about this

[YoshL]

so will there be sign ups, or just pm when you're done with stepping?