Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[brothaice]

Zen 2k5 by brothaice - bpm

Bpm? does that mean that my song is offsync? Because i know the end is a little off, because there is a slow down, but i dont know hot to figure out the bpm change. But other than the end, every thing else should be right.

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

When did I submit my five files? I forget.

[SulferDragon]

Originally Posted by Tasselfoot

Maxx Resurrexxion by SulferDragon - jacks, 24th trill, trills in general
{Colossus} by SulferDragon - bpm, jacks, trill before jacks

In other words, thrills are a no-no now

Uh, what's a thrill? (I'm damn serious)

[Tasselfoot]

ok... comments on the discussion files:


Frozen Bond - Shash made a typo... file is in queue
Cold Breath - we're both going to replay the 2 files and re-discuss
Elements of a Party - Shash is going to replay with my comments in mind
Melonman's OP - Shash is going to replay with my comments in mind
Piano Etude - in queue
Run to the Hills - we're both going to replay, cause neither of us remember the file
Maxx Attaxx - Shash is going to replay
Neon-213 - Shash is going to replay with my comments in mind
KilStage - need to resend the mp3 to Shash, his is corrupted for some reason, then he can play it and comment

Sail Away.... I thought it'd be easier to just C&P our conversation on the subject.
[23:12] Shashakiro: and the sail aways. whooo boy.
[23:13] TasselFoot: yup.
[23:13] Shashakiro: ilu's and brothaice's are both out
[23:13] TasselFoot: my rankings: blazze/jx, hi19, rebirth, macgravel. the other 3 i didn't +, and i threw them out of discussion.
[23:13] Shashakiro: uh
[23:13] Shashakiro: I didn't mind flip's oni
[23:13] Shashakiro: which is all I played
[23:13] TasselFoot: i'd have ranked flip's 5th, like you did... so i commented on it and put it elsewhere.
[23:14] Shashakiro: k
[23:14] TasselFoot: we both have hi19's as 2nd.
[23:14] Shashakiro: I think Rebirth's is too streamy
[23:14] Shashakiro: was my biggest complaint with that
[23:14] TasselFoot: i felt rebirth's WOULD have been 1st... it had the best patterns... if he had broken his 2nd stream in the middle down into bursts.
[23:14] Shashakiro: yeah
[23:14] TasselFoot: i already told him this. and i assume he'll fix it.
[23:14] TasselFoot: and then his will be the best.
[23:14] TasselFoot: which will make all of this moot, alas.
[23:15] Shashakiro: I think jx+blazze's had a few 16ths in funny places
[23:15] Shashakiro: wouldn't put that high up there
[23:15] TasselFoot: i had no comments on jx's or hi19s.
[23:15] Shashakiro: I'm going from memory
[23:15] TasselFoot: macgravels... i didn't like the fact that the whole file was trills
[23:15] Shashakiro: I do remember these
[23:15] Shashakiro: personally I liked the trills
[23:16] Shashakiro: I dunno, I wouldn't mind hi's going in at all
[23:16] TasselFoot: i think the fact that we both had generally no complaint on hi19s, and had his ranked 2nd for both... is good enough to make his the current queue file.
[23:16] Shashakiro: was really close between them
[23:16] Shashakiro: yeah sure
[23:16] TasselFoot: right. me too. was very close between hi19 and jx's for me.
[23:16] TasselFoot: between 1/2
[23:16] Shashakiro: yeah
[23:16] Shashakiro: we'll use hi's then
So hi19hi19's file of Sail Away is the one that makes the cut!













EDIT: Brothaice... the bpm is wrong
SulferDragon... see the FFR Picture Dictionary for any and all issues on terminology. It's located as a sticky in either FFR General Talk or Newbie Forum (i forget which).

[brothaice]

Originally Posted by SulferDragon

In other words, thrills are a no-no now

Uh, what's a thrill? (I'm damn serious)

left-down-left-down-left-down-left-down

right-up-right-up-right-up-right-up-right-up-

etc-etc-etc-etc-etc-etc-etc-etc-etc-etc-

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

Shit.

[SulferDragon]

Wow, I feel like a noob. I always thought thrills were... (you don't wanna know) okay, gotcha! ty :P

[Shashakiro]

It's called a trill.

T-R-I-L-L. Not "thrill". TRILL.

as amusing as Nul's misspelling was, I think it'd be good for you to know how the term is actually spelled.

[rednanaki]

I forgot, are my three re-submissions in my great big package too?

[Valtrix]

Guys...isn't it sad that you're asking what you've sent? Can't you either one, remember, or two, check your sent folder? >_>

[brothaice]

seriously, if (-bpm) means the bpm is wrong, then what are some programs you guys use to get the bpm? I used Virtual DJ.

[dore]

I use a stopwatch and a little simple math for BPM. For BPM changes I use the guess and check method.

[macgravel]

Use Mix Meister BPM Analyzer to check your BPM. As long as the song doesn't change BPM, it should give you a solid BPM.

[rednanaki]

Originally Posted by Valtrix

Guys...isn't it sad that you're asking what you've sent? Can't you either one, remember, or two, check your sent folder? >_>

It WAS two weeks ago, and my sent folder deletes itself after like two days.

[Rebirth0]

AAA - At first I had no idea what the hell you were talking about, but I see now. That's how the music is, it's not me that did it. You can either have it like it is, or I can move everything up or down an 8th note. But that means that the downbeat of the first 22 seconds of the song would be a blue/8th note, and so would the last 22 seconds. Are you fine with that?

Euro Freak - The damn thing feels like it goes to the music, and in SM it would be fun. Fine, I'll change it

V1 - I thought it was somewhat fun and challenging. Silver Brian's better be good then.

Winter Shiki -It's Winter Shiki, not Winter. Are you talking about the first big stream? Measures 22 and 23? Listen to the music, Those are IN THE MUSIC, I just listened to the thing at 0.7x.

[Blazze_.]

Well since my sail away was really close to getting in (tass had it first and shash had a little problem with the stream) could jx or I possibly fix it up and still get it accepted over hi19's?

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

Maybe as a v2.
(Blazze is Blaaaaazzze...)

[brothaice]

K, i think i fixed it. The whole song was slow by .08, and im pretty sure i got the ending.

Sidenote: I just finished cranky -260, ~425 jumps =]

[Shashakiro]

Originally Posted by Rebirth0

But that means that the downbeat of the first 22 seconds of the song would be a blue/8th note, and so would the last 22 seconds. Are you fine with that?

Uh yeah, since those fall on 8ths...

V1 - I thought it was somewhat fun and challenging. Silver Brian's better be good then.

It's easier. I thought it was a lot more fun, personally.

[Silver_Brian]

It's fairly simple and follows the main notes. I didn't really want to make it like Kilga's.