FFR Community Pack

[omgitznpv]

I've accepted three files out of the six, myself. I'll have to re-judge Scatter v4, though, so it may become four.

Keep in mind that it just so happens that this batch was decent, overall. I, myself, am not expecting there to be more than two files accepted per batch, assuming each batch has around the same number of files.

[Coolboyrulez0]

I can submit my ultimate geno's forest simfile but you would reject because edit, even though its innovative. Heavy and Oni are good imo.
also i need good cd title plz

[omgitznpv]

Um, if its edit then there's no reason for me to reject it.

[EnR]

Yea rofl, edit is just a random file that prob doesn't even need to be judged since it's just a bs file.

[dorama]

sending a file to this so yeah

[omgitznpv]

Alright, cool.

Also, EnR, your sig is too big.

I'll re-judge Scatter v4 once I get home; probably around 8-9ish.

[Nightfirecat]

Ok, finally home... Here's my reviews straight from the notepad xD

Call of the Anceints (V2)-Mixmasterlar
	x/xx
	Steps were mediocre in most parts, holds were placed a little akwardly, offsync in some parts... resync. Fix difficulty--more like a 12 rather than a 14... Some steps towards the beginning were stepped to no notes.

Elysium-Kommisar
	xxx/xxxx
	Pretty good steps... Some parts seemed under/overstepped, but very good for the most part. Felt like there were a few too many holds in the beginning, after the very start of the intro.

Hardkore Atomic-EnR
	xxx
	Steps were pretty good--especially towards the end. Some mini-holds were unnecessary. Maybe try stepping the entire rythym in the holds section in the middle.

LEAVE BRITNEY ALONE!-moches
	xx
	Steps at the beginning of the song were extremely repetitive, but they got a bit better at the end. Consider trying to resync a little as well? In oni mode, make it a bit more random--felt like a lot of the same patterns over and over again.

Scatter v4-Berzerker
	xxx
	Steps were good overall. Only consideration would be to not do the freeze then tap note right at the end 2 times in a row. Also, maybe try and redo the section around 500 notes to not be so repetitive.

Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate (New Take)-omgitznpv
	xxx/xxxx
	Good steps. Couldn't find anything wrong with it. Some steps seemed a bit wierd, but it seems like it's fine like it is.

All in all, I think that britney and ancients shouldn't go ahead. Britney just needs some fixing up... Ancients really needs to just go get completely redone... Or seriously edited.

[EnR]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

Alright, cool.

Also, EnR, your sig is too big.

I'll re-judge Scatter v4 once I get home; probably around 8-9ish.

My sig is smaller then yours rofl.

[Nightfirecat]

Ok, well that picture is f***ing huge, ok?

And it takes like a minute to read...

[moches]

Okay, so Elysium and Gachagacha are our two accepted files. Pretty much everyone loved them. Both could stand to fix some minor niggles though, they're still accepted.

Leave Britney Alone, Scatter, and Hardkore need some work.

Updated the accepted list.

edit: Lol mine is bigger than any of yours xD

[EnR]

I'll work on HA, I got uhm 6 stars that i know of, i don't know what you (moches and kommi have me)

[Coolboyrulez0]

make me a cd title that isnt crap and you get my file(s)
thats how it works here.

[Nightfirecat]

Originally Posted by moches

Submitted Files

BATCH 1
1. Berzerkr- Scatter v4 (released) http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...p?songid=23970
2. MixMasterLar- Call of the Ancients v2 (released) http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...p?songid=23990
3. EnR- Hardkore Atomic (fixed)
4. Kommisar- Elysium
5. moches- Leave Britney Alone (Trance Mix)
6. omgitznpv- Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate (New Take)

BATCH 2



Accepted Files
1. Kommisar- Elysium
6. omgitznpv- Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate (New Take)

Take another look at the accepted files... You numbered them wrong >.>

[buizel8888]

If you guys still want any more help, I could help out in judging.
Also I maybe be able to get a couple files into this thing, for the hell of it

[moches]

Originally Posted by Nightfirecat

Take another look at the accepted files... You numbered them wrong >.>

Oh snap, you're right. xD Fixed.

Also buizel8888 I think we have all the judges we need, we'd love to have some of your stuff in here though.

[buizel8888]

Originally Posted by moches

Oh snap, you're right. xD Fixed.

Also buizel8888 I think we have all the judges we need, we'd love to have some of your stuff in here though.

i sent one of my released files to you, since the ffr simfile database gets no traffic. It will get there one gmail gets off its period.

edit: you have it now

[who_cares973]

still stepping files!

[omgitznpv]

to be honest i was actually a bit inconsistent with my judging this time. some days i felt like giving a bit more leniency.

here's my notes if you guys really care:

Batch 1 Reviews (omgitznpv)



Scatter v4 (Berzerkr)

x/xxxx

Not good. Inconsistent like heck; jump/hand placement is obviously incorrect and very terrible. The jack placement in this file is badly done, and this song also has a LOT more potential IMO.


Call of the Ancients v2 (MixMasterLar)

x/xxxx

Uh, this is kind of badly synced. A lot of jump placement is incorrect. Not fun, either.
Have you heard of a concept called "layering?"



Hardkore Atomic (EnR)

xxx/xxxx
Finally fixed it up, eh? Missing jump at m49 but hopefully the other judges can place a jump there...
It could be a lot better, though, if the song had more point to it. This is near the best it can be IMO.



Elysium (Kommisar)

xxx/xxxx
Good file overall.
Gap appears to be off by a few insignicant milliseconds.
m25-33 seems like it could be improved a bit to me.
I think you can start the 16th stream at m35.

Leave Britney Alone (Trance Mix) (moches)

xx/xxxx

Both charts:
Decent. The song and steps are really repetitive for me, though. I think you can layer a bit more with this and have it be a bit more fun as a result. The gap is also off by 20-ish ms for me.

Oni Chart:
The ending is also kind of gay to me.



Gachagacha Cute Figu@mate (New Take) (npv)

xxxx/xxxx

Well, it's my own file, so yeah. I think it's pretty cool and really fun, though since it's a fixed up version of my original file, it's stepped a bit differently than I would have done it now. Still quite awesome to me anyways.




also, and about gachagacha cute figu@mate (new take), i know it has stuff that can be worked out. however, a few points are that it might not be fun enough, i dont songcut really unless its absolutely necessary, people can see my slightly old stepping style, and the fact that im just a bit lazy

expect a really hot gachagacha hertz figu@radio tho

[Nightfirecat]

You gave ratings almost EXACTLY the same as I did... Except you hated scatter. xD

BTW: I'll have a file done for this in 2 days or so.. maybe 3.

[EnR]

Me too, I'm planning on stepping the full version of Jelly Roll Blues and Wish Liszt (Toy Shop Madness) [Instrumental] by Trans-Siberian Orchestra.