Stepmania Idol [KB Pack]

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by dragoonhead

Thanks,now with this stupidity i have a really great reason to refused any dragonforce songs in this pack

OK now you're just coming across like a jerk. I sent you a PM a while ago adressing that issue asking if it'd possibly prevent it from qualifying. When you didn't reply I submitted it anyways since it has never been released as an isolated file (which, again, I already specified). I then reference the PM and you're calling me an idiot? And how can this instance reflect an entire band?

Completely disregarding how this directly impacts me, this is discouraging considering that you seem to be in charge of this pack. Consequently I'm questioning this pack's success as its failure may very well prove to be attributed to your poor operating skills. I know there are other team members, but as I understood it, you're managing this project. Am I correct?

Just no need for demeaning comments.

[kommisar[os]]

he just means it's a really really bad idea to step dragonforce

[trumaestro]

the "policy" is pretty much absolutely no released files either as a single or in another pack. same with most sm packs.
dragonforce is pretty awful song choice. it's one of the reasons i reject your file, but it's not the only one. i can go in depth on it via pm for you if you want, but try to pick better songs to submit here, especially ones that you haven't released yet.

what's in the pack so far is pretty good, but everything else that has been submitted so far is pretty much crap.

[N.T.M.]

Originally Posted by trumaestro

the "policy" is pretty much absolutely no released files either as a single or in another pack. same with most sm packs.
dragonforce is pretty awful song choice. it's one of the reasons i reject your file, but it's not the only one. i can go in depth on it via pm for you if you want, but try to pick better songs to submit here, especially ones that you haven't released yet.

what's in the pack so far is pretty good, but everything else that has been submitted so far is pretty much crap.

Thank you for the serious reply. That's all I asked ^_^. Initially I was hoping to clarify that before I tried submitting it, but days went by without any response. And I know you've got great credibility with your criticism so I'd certainy be interested to get some more info. The thing is I was kinda unsure what to do for some places. I mentioned this in the text document included in the file. For example: say you wanna layer the guitar with the drums. Now just a normal 16th trill would technically be incorrect (assuming there's more detail for the sae of this point), yet the guitar is 8th note jacks. What should be done in places like this? Just step the guitar? Step the drums and compromise guitar accuracy? Layer but compromise the drum role accuracy? I also wasn't sure what parts I should repeat or not. I mean if you change it up it's technically inconsistent, but if you don't it may get boring. I'm kinda unsure what the perfect balance is . I lot of these issues are attributed to song choice though.

[alexdestructions]

Originally Posted by trumaestro

ps i never downloaded your chipscape. you need to spend a whole bunch of time on one original file and then maybe i'll care

I've spent like 3 weeks on chipscape. =\ That was enough time.

[buizel8888]

File quality

Time spent on the file x The person's stepping ability
--------------------------------------------------------------- = Quality of the file
----------------------some constant


i'm sorry but from what i have heard, you aren't a very good stepper, so that 3 weeks is being multiplied by a pretty low number

[kommisar[os]]

skills x time played
------------------- / song choice - elitist reviews = absolutely nothing fool
actual knowlege

[buizel8888]

Don't be attacking my math

It was checked over by an azn so its gotta be correct

[kommisar[os]]

no i'm just being honest with people who think playing a long amount of time means you're good at making files.

[Mr. Bob]

submitting Take It Easy now

[buizel8888]

Oh

my bad. We're still cool rite

[kommisar[os]]

i actually hate you magus

[buizel8888]

Oh, rshadow avatar jokes

ver funny.


also the next song i step will be for this. I have a gud idea of something now

[kommisar[os]]

pre-accepted

[moches]

I almost forgot to ask, but did you guys get my Sayonara Heaven fix?

[trumaestro]

moches: yep
mrbob: resend your file. got no attachment/link
ntm: i'll look at it after school
alex: PICK ORIGINAL SONGS!! If you can't do that then pick some half decent song with ****ty index steps from some old pack that hasn't been redone yet. I'll look at your file, but it'll get rejected just like the other 15 or so files you've sent.

collab anyone? you pick the song; nothing too dumb plz

[Brilliant Dynamite Neon]

Are you not reviewing my file for lack of graphics?

[kommisar[os]]

not at all. graphics aren't a requirement

[Jolt Bolt]

Originally Posted by kommisar[os]

skills x time played
------------------- / song choice - elitist reviews = absolutely nothing fool
actual knowlege

division by zero!

[sakura080789]

hmmm about to submit something now lol correction 2 files